Ensuring Consistent Oversight for Animal Welfare

Understanding the critical importance of statewide consistency in the inspection of animal shelters, pounds, kennels, and pet shops across New Jersey.

Why consistent inspections of New Jersey animal shelters are not optional—they are essential

The Canine Corner understands that the situation unfolding in places like Vineland is not an isolated dispute. It highlights a broader, systemic issue in New Jersey: inconsistent oversight of animal shelters by the New Jersey Department of Health, and a failure to align that oversight with the statutory obligations imposed on municipalities. (This is not about one shelter - it is about the inspection process, lack thereof, and inconsistencies, and lack of involvement by the NJDOH.)

 

Vineland was not simply a contract dispute. It presented a question of whether New Jersey’s regulatory framework is being applied consistently to protect animals, public health, and community safety.  It questioned why NJDOH declined to get involved.

The law is clear: municipalities must provide animal control and impoundment

The law is clear: municipalities must provide animal control and impoundment

Under New Jersey law, municipalities are required to provide animal control services, including the seizure and impoundment of animals.

  • N.J.S.A. 4:19-15.16 mandates the appointment of animal control officers and enforcement of animal control laws.
  • N.J.S.A. 4:19-15.1 and related provisions require that animals taken into custody be impounded in a proper facility.
  • N.J.A.C. 8:23A requires that these facilities be licensed and regulated by NJDOH.

These legal mandates underscore the necessity of robust and consistent inspection processes. Without proper oversight, the welfare of impounded animals and the safety of our communities are at risk.  Oversight and training of those who oversee the inspections fall to the NJDOH.

Common questions and concerns about inspections

We understand that shelters, pounds, kennels, and pet shops, along with those in the communities that foot the bill for these services, may have questions and concerns regarding inspection processes. Here are some of the most common worries we aim to address:

  • Consistency of standards: How can we ensure that all facilities are held to the same standard across different municipalities and by different inspectors?
  • Transparency: What is the process for inspection, and how can facilities access clear guidelines and reports?
  • Support for compliance: What resources are available to help facilities meet and maintain inspection standards, especially for smaller organizations or those with limited resources?
  • Addressing discrepancies: What is the procedure for addressing inconsistencies or disputes that may arise during an inspection?
  • Impact on operations: How will inspections affect daily operations, and what steps can be taken to minimize disruption?

The Canine Corner advocates for a transparent, consistent, and supportive inspection framework that benefits both facilities and the animals. For more information or to report concerns, please contact Dr. Darby McDermott, NJDOH at darby.mcdermott@doh.nj.gov or 609-826-4872.